Sunday, 9 November 2014

50 mm APCR Effectiveness

While exploring the confusion among Soviet battlefield investigators with German HEAT and APCR shells, kris_reid discovered the following curious fragment.


"...62 mm of armour was penetrated. A notable characteristic of this penetration was that both shells exploded in the fighting compartment without harming anyone, aside from the company commander, who was stunned.

During the same day, another Valentine was sent out without proper preparation, and was also hit.
Conclusions:
  1. There are still combined forces commanders that do not understand tank tactics.
  2. The enemy has a long-barrelled 50 mm anti-tank gun that fires thermite shells that can burn through 62 mm of armour. The shell itself burns up and the remainder is ineffective at harming the crew."
50 mm gun firing HEAT shells? Of course not. The damage described (little internal damage, no trace of shell) is characteristic of APCR. After penetrating the armour, the hard tungsten carbide core shatters into small pieces, which are difficult to recognize as a penetrating element. 

Saturday, 8 November 2014

Anti-Molotov Grilles


"On October 14th, 1939, as a part of testing program approved by the chief engineer of factory #174, trials of experimental engine grilles were performed to test the permeation of flame and incendiary fluid into the engine compartment.

Trials were conducted on a T-26 tank with the engine working at 2000 RPM. Gasoline in bottles was used as an incendiary fluid, which were thrown at the engine grille, and ignited by open flame near the grille openings.

Trials showed that despite a large amount of gasoline (13 bottles), no burning fluid seeped into the engine compartment. Flames sucked in by the cooling system scorched the insulation on high voltage wiring. As the wiring was burned out, the engine reduced its revolutions, and stopped completely after some wires crossed. As well as the insulation, the rubber lining by the turret platform was burned by the flame. The flame did not affect the gasoline tank.

Based on aforementioned trials, it can be stated that the experimental grille can protect the engine compartment from penetration by burning fluids. Observations after the engine stopped showed that the gasoline fully evaporated from the carburettor."

V. Lehn Collection

Friday, 7 November 2014

Tractor Trouble

For the Soviet Union, the start of the Great Patriotic War happened at a very poor time. Yes, everyone knows about restructuring after purges and rebuilding fortifications at new borders, but few people know about another problem: a shortage of artillery tractors. Existing tractors no longer fully satisfied the RKKA, and projects to replace them haven't really taken off. The loss of major industrial centers during this time didn't help.

"To the chief of the GABTU Auto-Tractor Directorate

In a response to the inquiry by the 3rd department of the GABTU ATU, I report the list of artillery systems that require tractors for towing. Currently, factories do not produce any tractors to tow them, and it is impossible to replace them with foreign made tractors, as they are too weak.
  1. 107 mm M-60 gun: 4300 kg
  2. 76 mm AA gun model 1931: 4970 kg
  3. 152 mm model 1910/34 gun: 7820 kg
  4. 122 mm model 1931 gun: 7800 kg
  5. 152 mm model 1937 gun: 7930 kg
  6. 203 mm model 1931 howitzer "B-4":  18150 kg (transported in pieces)
  7. 152 mm model 1937 gun "Br-2": 18345 kg (transported in pieces)
  8. 280 mm mortar "Br-5": 18420 kg (transported in pieces)
  9. 210 mm gun "Br-17": 20800 kg (transported in pieces)
  10. 305 mm howitzer "Br-18": 20800 kg (transported in pieces)
In order to tow these guns, the Red Army artillery branch (newly formed regiments, high power regiments, front artillery regiments) needs 3300 tractors.

Additionally, no tractors are being built to tow guns that weigh less than 3000 kg. Currently, foreign wheeled tractors are being used for this task that, naturally, cannot be a good replacement for an artillery tractor. 

6000 tractors are needed to towing guns that weigh less than 3 tons."


Here is how the guns were transported. The heavy Komintern tractor could take a B-4 all by itself.


But the lighter and weaker Kommunar needed help, either by attaching two tractors to one gun or towing it in two pieces. 



Thursday, 6 November 2014

Engine-Hours

Guderian's saying about an engine being as much of a weapon as a tank's gun could not have been more true about WWII, where operations failed or succeeded not because of millimeters of armour and gun caliber, but mobility, strategic and operational, allowing the destruction of massive groups of enemies. I have already explored the reliability of some vehicles, but what about the ones that are lesser known, but no less important than big names like T-34 and Sherman?


The above is a table of vehicles that arrives for repairs at Repair Base #7 in December of 1940. The columns are as follows:
  1. Number (column largely cut off by scanner)
  2. Unit
  3. Region and dislocation
  4. Vehicle type (A-26 is T-26, A-7 is BT-7, A-5 is BT-5, and A-2 is BT-2)
  5. Date of arrival
  6. Hull number
  7. Engine number
  8. Engine-hours total
  9. Engine hours since last repairs
With some vehicles, we're seeing some pretty good numbers! Data on the T-26 is sparse, but the one that has had its time calculated is at a whole 195 hours and 20 minutes! Although, its neighbour has only worked 86 hours before landing in the repair bay, so that's not exactly a good showing. For all the flak BT tanks caught for using worn our aircraft engines, they seem to be doing pretty well. An aged BT-2 clocks in at as much as 284 hours and 10 minutes, and 179 hours from the other isn't too shabby. Overall, there aren't any poor showers from the BT series, with the worst performer only working for 100.5 hours since it was last repaired. Overall, the tanks are pretty robust as well, raking in hundreds of engine hours over their entire lifespan. Clearly, by 1940, the BT was a refined and mature design. Sadly, by this time it was completely obsolete.

Speaking of obsolete tanks, other pages in the folder include the tanks being sent off from the repair base back to the army after being fixed. These tanks include a fair number of dual-turreted T-26es, tanks that have been out of production for nearly a decade at this point!

Wednesday, 5 November 2014

Preliminary Inspection

Here is a report of a new German vehicle captured by Soviet forces in the later half of January 1943. Can you guess what it is?

"The captured tank near Workers' Village #5 has the following tactical-technical characteristics:
  1. Combat mass: 75-80 tons
  2. Size:
    1. Length: 6.25 meters
    2. Width: 3.6 meters
    3. Height: 2.95 meters
    4. Clearance: 0.4 meters
  3. Armour:
    1. Front: 110 mm
    2. Side: 75 mm
    3. Horizontal: 30 mm
    4. Turret: 65 mm
    5. Rear: 80 mm
    6. Driver's viewport: 190 mm
  4. Armament:
    1. 1 88 mm gun
    2. 2 7.6 mm machineguns
  5. Ammunition:
    1. 86 88 mm shells
  6. Amount of fuel tanks: 4
  7. Amount of oil tanks: 1
  8. Engine: Maybach, engine power unknown at up to 4000 RPM
  9. Track length in contact with ground: 4.5 meters
  10. Track width: 0.73 m
  11. Crew: 5
  12. Sights and periscopes: 3
The vehicle is controlled with an oil-hydraulic system. The gearbox is oil-hydraulic, 8 speed, positioned in the front of the vehicle."

This is a clearly preliminary report, as the information is, well, rather off, but there can be no question about it, this vehicle is one of the first Tiger tanks captured by the Red Army.

Tuesday, 4 November 2014

World of Tanks History Section: Mikhail Svirin: Man, Historian, Soldier

Mikhail Svirin was one of the historians that opened up an entirely new history of armoured vehicles, based on documents declassified in the late 80s and early 90s. These people laid down the foundation on which a new generation of researchers is building their work even now. Unfortunately, in May of this year, he passed away. The editor in chief of the publisher "Tactical Press", Gregoriy Pernavskiy, writes about Svirin, having known this exceptional man personally:

There are people that appear in your life and disappear without any noticeable trace. Others walk the same path as you, and even if they leave, you will always think what they would say when you do something. Mikhail Nikolayevich was one of those people.

I try to remember who we met through in the second half of the 1990s. I remember only that it was long before the rise of the "Military-Historical Forum" that gave the world a generation of authors which turned the world of military history upside down. These people were already in the second generation. They knew where to go, and, most important, what to look for.

Svirin was a part of the first generation of military history enthusiasts, and a history enthusiast in general. In those days, no doors opened for us. The only historical education came from the state. Enthusiasts, amateurs, those of us with hot hearts, had no place in this system. We did not give up. Through back doors, we gained access to technical libraries, talked to "elders" from design bureaus, met up with other enthusiasts. Slowly, as concrete cracks under great pressure, the dogmas of the old system fell.

In the 1990s, new books and magazines were printed. They were few in number, and for us enthusiasts, they were worth their weight in gold. They were traded, Xeroxed, given visible places in collections. The names Svirin, Kolomiyets, Baryatinskiy were known to all that are connected to military history. They deserve this fame. These three men rolled the boulder up the hill, and due to their efforts, many stars rose, and continue to rise.

As for "Uncle Misha", he achieved many things: founded the excellent military historical "Polygon" magazine for model enthusiasts. Alas, it did not survive. Turns out that amateur researchers don't have extra money. In order to publish his book on the T-28, Svirin sold his car. People are split into "effective managers" and those who do real things, strive and suffer for them. These are people from two different worlds.

Without his magazine, Svirin started the most difficult project of his life. He wrote his magnum opus "History of the Soviet Tank", known to all armoured vehicle enthusiasts. Mikhail Nikolayevich was not just a writer, he was a true scientist. His main talent was combining military and political history, explaining the reasons why engineers settled on one decision or other.

Of course, Svirin's book is not the gospel truth. It contains mistakes, leaps of faith, imperfections. It describes far from all dramatic episodes in the history of Soviet tank building. This is easily explained. What modern enthusiasts have easy access to was simply impossible for enthusiasts of the 70s and 80s. Conclusions were often made with incomplete or distorted information. Nevertheless, aside from maybe encyclopedias, there is no overall history of the Soviet tank, and will not be for a long time.

Aside from books, Uncle Misha wrote for internet resources and forums. Meetings with him became fascinating and unique lectures. In his last years, he almost entirely switched to a patriotic upbringing of children and teenagers, and stopped writing, mostly because he has said most of what he wanted. Most, but not all. His health failed him. The wounds of the "peaceful war" (Svirin took part in mine clearing in Checnya and suffered concussions there) took their toll.

For years, his injuries caused him horrible pain. Any other man would have turned into a furious beast, but not Svirin. He was nearly an avatar of good. Himself in need of help, he was always ready to offer a helping hand and at least contribute advice. He had friends that were always ready to help, Maksim Kolomiyets, Sergey Burkatovskiy, Aleksandr Kontorovich, and many more. Uncle Misha was a truly great man and a real fighter. He knew that his cause was just, and he never surrendered.

Article author: Grigoriy Pernavskiy

Original article available here.

Monday, 3 November 2014

World of Tanks History Section: "Transformers" of the World Wars

All Terrain Meteor: An armoured train-tank
September, 1941. A medic from Syzran, V.N. Emelyanov, decided not to waste time and send his invention straight to Stalin: “Super-speed universal all-terrain armoured train-tank”. The author insisted that his creation can “travel on rails by itself or towing a load at up to 200 kph, on land it can go over mountains and ravines, it can swim in water regardless of depth of width of rivers”. Emelyanov’s letter was sent to GABTU, but did not impress its specialists. From the included papers, it could be seen that such a vehicle would have poor off-road performance, low maneuverability, and the entire thing was too bulky.

Emelyanov was not distraught, and continued to improve his invention for two years. As a result, the proposed mass of the tank shrank by a factor of 3, and it gained the ability to travel on rail and ground with wheels, as well as tracks. The new project had an equally glamorous title: “Universal armoured train-tank METEOR”.

Emelyanov described his invention as follows: “The METEOR comes off the railroad and engages its tracks, allowing it to go around any obstacle, after which it can return to the railroad… due to its super high speed, the probability of the METEOR being hit by enemy shells or bombs is reduced”. The tank switched between tracks and wheels with automatic jacks. The incredible speed (200 kph) would be obtained by replacing the locomotive transmission with a hydraulic one. All mechanisms of the suspension and the movement of the vehicle would be powered by only one steam cylinder. The transmission would be covered with reliable armour. The boiler, also armoured, was supposed to be “omnivorous”. It could consume coal, kerosene, oil, wood, or even straw. Despite Emelyanov’s efforts, GABTU specialists remained uninterested, and his projects remained on paper.

Double Tankette "Sark": Fool your enemy!

Muscovites A.A. Smirnov and K.N. Romanov came up with a non-trivial design in 1945. They named their puzzling project "Sark".

What was so original about it? According to the authors "the vehicle is made from two identical looking moving vehicles, in order to disguise the real vehicle".

Both tankettes were connected with a sturdy cable, which powered the engine of the secondary vehicle. The energy was provided by a DC generator in the main vehicle. The cable was about 800 meters long, and the secondary tankette was to have a wooden spool for it. Only one person was required to drive the main vehicle, as Smirnov and Romanov described: "The main vehicle is driven by a single person, lying down. He controls it with levers next to his hands and feet. In order to stabilize the soldier, there is a cushioned saddle on which he can lean when lying down or sitting up." The driver was also cushioned with shoulder belts and a cushion on the ceiling.

Why did the "Sark" have to come in a pair? The authors did not give it much thought. They mentioned that the "copy" covering the main tanketter can serve as a moving bomb, carrying explosives and blowing up enemy fortifications or vehicles as far away as the cable could take it. 

The only historical inspiration for the invention would be assault barrels. In wars of the past, as late as WWI, they were filled with gunpowder, striking elements (chunks of metal, shrapnel, bullets), equipped with a fuse, and rolled at the enemy that was besieging the fortress. However, making and using such improvised weapons was definitely much cheaper than the proposed cost of the Sark project.

Modular All-terrain Armoured Vehicle

Emelyanov, Smirnov, and Romanov's projects are far from the first. Thirty years before that, modular and all-terrain vehicles were already on the mind of inventors.

In the end of March of 1916, Horatio Thomas Lyell, a British citizen from Essex, sent a message to the Russian diplomat in London, Count Benkendorf titled "A description of an improved combined motorized motor vehicle, a car-sled-boat-seaplane". Lyell described a vehicle that was like a boat with propellers, capable of moving over any surface without loss of speed, due to its swappable suspension: wheels, pontoons, or runners. The two-man crew, according to the engineer, could swap between the three with little effort. The armament was weak, only one machinegun. This weakness in battle was to be compensated by mobility, and the ability to maneuver on any terrain. The letter stated that a proposal was sent to the British military in 1914, but they showed no interest. Two years later, Russian specialists received it no better.

In December of that same year, P.S. Marchenko from Odessa offered an invention to the Minister of War in Russia, Infantry General D.S. Shuvayev. His design was composed of independent modules. Two damaged vehicles could be combined into one working one in the field. This armoured cruiser was to be armed with six 75 mm ship guns, four machineguns, and 2 AA guns. Sadly, the author did not add a picture of his design, and only described it.

Today, many proposals from the pages of history trigger a smile. They remain as a testament to the struggles of engineering thought on the difficult path from the start of tank design to its heights. The inventors, whichever nation the served, strived for victory on the front line, and their projects await researches in the archives.

Article author: Yuri Bakhurin. Yuri Bakhurin is a military historian, an author of many publications in regional and central scientific press: "Questions of History" magazine, "Military-Historical Magazine", "Military-Historical Archive", "Motherland", "Anthology of War", the "Reitar" almanac, and many more. He is also the author of the "Panzerjager Tiger (P) Ferdinand: Use in Combat" book.

Sources:
  • RGVIA 803-1-1829
  • RGVIA 803-1-1817
  • CAMD RF 38-11350-591
  • CAMD RF 38-11350-1695
  • V.F. Sperk, Fortifikatsionniy Slovar, Moscow, 1946
Original article available here.

Sunday, 2 November 2014

SU-7 Ergonomics

A lot of people complain about how you could only work in Soviet tanks if you were very short. The SU-14 exhibits the exact opposite trend.


_tezka provides a caption for this image: "The photograph characterizes the uncomfortable working conditions of the loader when operating the crane with the shell and propellant." He is nowhere tall enough to crank the handle comfortably, and must stand on some equipment in order to put him in a good position. Perhaps someone should have brought a crate for him to stand on.


And here's a picture of the whole vehicle, simply because you don't see one of these every day.

Saturday, 1 November 2014

Penetration, SNAFU Edition

This penetration table holds no new information, and just contains data copied from this table, except only the guns made for heavy tanks made it into the copy.


Yawn. But wait, what is this? Zoom, enhance!


Wow, 900 millimeters of armour piercing action on that M-10! Send in the KV-2s, the Maus will stand no chance! Except...well let's make sure to double check that with the original table and... 900 mm rapidly becomes 90 mm. Oops. Remember, if it's too good to be true, it probably isn't!

Friday, 31 October 2014

ZiS-6 Project

"To the director of the Kirov factory, comrade Zaltsmann
To the GABTU Chief, Lieutenant-General of the Tank Forces, comrade Fedorenko

On the issue of mounting the 107 mm ZiS-6 gun in the KV-3 tank

Attached is the project for the installation of a 107 mm ZiS-6 gun in the KV-3 tank, which has the following characteristics:
  1. Muzzle velocity: 800 m/s
  2. Recoil resistance: 20,000 kg
  3. Mass of the recoil components: 1600 kg
  4. Mass of the oscillating components with the mantlet: 2600 kg
  5. Recoil length: 640+40 mm
  6. Shell: single piece
  7. Breech: semi-automatic
  8. Coaxial machinegun: DT
  9. Vertical gun range: +20 to -5
  10. Maximum vertical gun range obtainable with recoil brake: +40 to -15
  11. Fume extraction with compressed air is possible
  12. Shell casing length: 625 mm
  13. HE round length: approximately 1200 mm
  14. Initial return mechanism pressure: 50 atmospheres
  15. Sight: TD
  16. Mantlet: same as in the KV type turrets
  17. The gun will be tested in the KV-2 turret
Factory #92 is finishing the design of the ZiS-6. Despite this late stage, some improvements noted by your engineers will be made. Some of your requested changes cannot be made, as they require approval by the factory (the frame and mantlet are fixed in our design). 

The request from your engineers to use a two-piece shell goes against the decision of the party and government, which factory #92 will not allow. On our side, factory #92 did everything possible to ease the loading of a one piece shell, including making the gun as compact as possible.

In order to resolve the issue of two-piece loading, contact the appropriate authorities.

Factory director [signature]
Chief Engineer Grabin"